Vinyl vs. Aluminum Windows

Written on: March 20th, 2014 BY IN Windows

Do you need to replace your home’s old windows? You’re probably trying to decide on a material—and you have numerous options to choose from! Perhaps you’re considering vinyl and aluminum.

Which one should you get? Which is better—vinyl windows or aluminum windows? Overhead Door Co. of Indianapolis & Muncie can answer all your window questions, so continue reading to learn more about vinyl windows compared to aluminum.

Aluminum Windows vs. Vinyl Windows

No one window material is the best—it all depends on your needs and priorities. All materials have their own advantages. The factors most people look at when determining which type of windows they want include:

  • Energy efficiency
  • Durability
  • Maintenance
  • Price

Let’s see how vinyl windows and aluminum windows compare! Take a look at the table below.

Difference Between Vinyl and Aluminum Windows




Energy Efficiency Durability Maintenance Price Strength
Vinyl Good Good Good Good Fair
Aluminum Fair Good Good Fair Good


Aluminum windows only trump vinyl in terms of strength. These two windows have similar qualities, but vinyl is better in terms of:

  • Energy efficiency
  • Price

Aluminum windows tended to be more popular when energy prices were less of a concern. So if high energy efficiency and affordability are your biggest priorities, you may want to go with vinyl windows.

Vinyl Window Installation in Indianapolis

If you’re interested in replacing your old, drafty windows with new vinyl ones, you’ve come to the right place! Overhead Door Co. of Indianapolis & Muncie installs high-quality vinyl replacement windows from American Window and Great Lakes Window for homes throughout central Indiana.

We can install vinyl:

  • Casement windows
  • Awning windows
  • Single-hung windows
  • Double-hung windows
  • Slider windows
  • Bay and bow windows

Contact us today to learn more about our vinyl replacement window services!